by Arvalan
“Ten people who speak make more noise than ten thousand who are silent.” Napoleon Bonaparte
The terms Tamil Diaspora, expatriates and lobby are being used by the analysts and media frequently. This creates a perception that these terms are similar and is a matter of semantics. A lobby is “a group of persons who attempt to influence legislators or other public officials on behalf of some particular cause or interest” and lobbying means “to influence (legislators), or urge or procure the passage of” (Reference Macquarie dictionary.) The keyword in defining lobbyists and lobbying is influence”, which is defined as “power of producing effects by invisible or insensible means”.
One would ask the question whether the efforts of the Tamil diaspora are really lobbying as it lacks effective influencing. The concept of lobbying is paramount to the Tamil nation and the Tamil Diasporas at this critical juncture in our path to liberation. The fact that we are criticizing the International Community (IC) for inaction, inertia and impartialness towards the Sri Lankan government’s atrocities is testimony for lack of (if any) lobbying in the international arena. Here are some examples of the Tamil nation pleading with the IC in the recent past.
*”Propping up genocidal Sinhala State counterproductive, International Community should change approach”- The leader of the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE), V Pirapaharan, in his 2007 annual Heroes’ Day statement
* “The Indian State must take the responsibility for the ethnic genocide of the Tamils that will be carried out by the Sinhala military, re-invigorated by such moves of the Indian State,” Liberation Tigers of Tamileelam (LTTE) statement dated 10th March 2008.
* “LTTE urges Norway to take steps to end military assault on Madu shrine. Liberation Tigers”- Political Head B. Nadesan’s letter to the Norwegian government dated 7th of April 2008.
These pleas are the outcome of the failures in our lobbying effort and certainly these statements themselves do not constitute as a form of “effective lobbying”. “The right to be heard does not automatically include the right to be taken seriously.” said Hubert Humphrey former US Vice President. I believe at present this evidently portrays our efforts in the international political arena.
Our concerns and grievances have been heard by the IC. They understand our plight, sufferings and sacrifices. Why then does the IC do not act to support our justifiable cause? Or at least reprimand the Sri Lankan government for its atrocities?
The answer to this question partly lies in our inability to “influence” the decision makers in the IC, in other words our inability to lobby effectively. The efforts of the Diasporas in soliciting support from the IC cannot be classified as lobbying; it is classic propaganda. When you propagate you secure the right to be heard. That does not mean you have been taken seriously or that you have positively influenced the decision maker (which is what lobbying means).
Our propaganda efforts have so far secured speakers (Members of Parliament, Clergy, Human rights activists and Academics) for our gatherings to mark an assassination, massacre or even the remembrance day (marveerar narl). Does that mean we have lobbied effectively in the international arena?
I believe the Tamil nation should launch an effective lobbying strategy in the international community. As a first step towards this we should establish a Tamil nationalistic think tank, which should be the front that interacts with the academics, thinks tanks, non government agencies and governments in the IC. The think tank is non political and does not represent the Tamil nation in any negotiations. LTTE should remain as the sole political representatives of the Tamil nation in any political negotiations. This effort is not about isolating LTTE. This effort is about enhancing the efforts of the LTTE in the IC
It is essential that the think tank should not be affiliated to the LTTE. This will be an acid test for the LTTE and Tamil nationalists as in the history of our struggle there has never been a genuine voice representing the interests of the Tamils other than the LTTE. This has avoided infiltration of intelligence agencies in our struggle. However at the same time we have lost opportunities to lobby in the IC.
Due to the absence of Tamil nationalistic moderate voice the Tamil nation has been deprived of opportunities to lobby the decision makers in the IC. This vacuum is being filled by Douglas Devananda and Anandasangaree at present. In the case of the Sinhala nation, JVP is classified as extremists, which renders the SLFP or UNP governments moderates in the eyes of the IC. In the case of the Tamil nation the sole representatives LTTE are classified as extremists, which the IC is reluctant to engage with.
The Tamil National Alliance (TNA), British Tamil Association (BTA) or Australian Federation of Tamil Association (AFTA) are not considered as moderate voices as they are considered as LTTE’s front organizations. Therefore we need to establish a think tank of academics, professionals and ordinary Tamil nationalists, who are not perceived as affiliates of the LTTE to communicate with the decision makers in the IC. The think tank should not be restricted to professionals and academics and should include ordinary Tamil nationalists as well, as the ability to think and think effectively is not restricted to the “educated”.
The think tank will develop effective lobbying strategies to influence the decision makers, not just soliciting speakers for our forums. This will include discussions with the exemplary lobby groups from the Jewish, East Timorese, Kosovo and other communities to learn from their experience. The think tank will also open the door for the Tamil nation to engage with the decision makers in the IC and provide an opportunity to positively influence.
Secondly the Tamil community should integrate with the IC. For example the New Zealand Tamil Community’s participation the recent ANZAC day celebration is a forward step in terms of our lobbying efforts in that country. We need to integrate before expecting to influence. Electoral lobbying efforts of the Sydney Tamils in the recent federal elections in Australia, is another example of integration. Integration is the key to execute influence in the IC as evidenced by the role played by the American Jewish community.
Thirdly the Tamil community should “wine and dine” with the decision makers. It is a harsh fact that the Sinhalese community has mastered the art of wining and dining with the local decision makers. The Sinhala community organizes many socializing effects where the local politicians are invited to wine, dine and integrate with the Sinhalese community. These events include the dinner dances, Old school association gatherings, community award nights and to coincide with the cricket tours. The Tamil community should organize events such as the above to meet and greet with the decision makers as a first step for effective lobbying. The relationship that is built at these functions will form the basis for subsequent influencing efforts.
The purpose of this article is to throw in a different perspective and to be a thought starter. I understand that various expatriate groups are working with the same agenda and it is time that we pool our efforts together for the common well and lobby effectively.
Let me conclude with a quote from President Franklin D. Roosevelt “Okay, you’ve convinced me. Now go out there and bring pressure on me” and Sun Tzu, The Art of War “Those who do not know the plans of competitors cannot prepare alliances. Those who do not know the lay of the land cannot maneuver their forces. Those who do not use local guides cannot take advantage of the ground”
May 3rd, 2008
by D.B.S. Jeyaraj
The Chimera in Greek mythology was a fire – breathing monster with a lion’s head,goat’s body and a serpent’s tail. According to the mythical tale, the hero Bellerophon killed it with the help of the winged horse Pegasus.
Nowadays the word chimera is used at times when referring to a thing of hybrid character.Chimerical is the adjective derived from the noun chimera.
The Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) organization is ostensibly fighting for the goal of national liberation. The LTTE wants to set up an independent state called Tamil Eelam comprising the Tamil dominated Northern and Tamil majority Eastern provinces of Sri Lanka.
The tigers are often chimerical in the methods used to pursue their goal. Their mode of armed struggle has trilateral aspects.
The LTTE adopts positional warfare like a conventional army or militia when it is trying to capture or defend territory. It engages in guerilla attacks when it targets the armed forces or Police. The tigers indulge in terrorism when innocent civilians are killed in bomb attacks or while assassinating democratic leaders and officials.
The tigers have in the past used all three modes. This mixed methodology makes it difficult to “label” the tigers effectively. Friend and foe would selectively pick what they want and brand the LTTE accordingly.
Some treat each act of the LTTE on an individual basis. In what seems to be a very simplistic approach ,each instance is treated on a case by case basis and categorised accordingly .
Events of the past weeks have demonstrated the LTTE’s trifold dimensions effectively.
In the North, the LTTE is engaging in positional warfare to defend the territory it holds. The tigers have been fighting the armed forces on multiple fronts in Mannar, Muhamaalai and Manal Aaru.
The high watermark in this was the manner in which a military push by elements of the 53 and 55 divisions were beaten back on the Muhamaalai front.
As for guerilla attacks there was the landmine attack in Thutuwewa killing 2 Special task Force personnel and the pressure mine explosion at Kalmadhu in which Capt. Bandara, Lt. Ratnayake, Cpl.Wickramaratne and Pvt. Padmasiri of the 6 Vijaya regiment travelling in a tractor were killed.
[VaanPuligal-pic:Eelavision]
The more spectacular attack was done by air when the LTTE’s fledgling air wing known as “Vaanpuligal” dropped three bombs in the Manal aaru / Weli Oya region.Once again tiger aircraft were able to drop explosives and get away safely despite the reportedly set up air defence systems.
The LTTE received much kudos for its fighting prowess in Muhamaalai and its Air tiger exploit in Weli – Oya/Manal Aaru. Both demonstrated that the LTTE was a fierce fighting force and could not be written off lightlly.
Yet, whatever its gains in the positional warfare and guerilla attack spheres , the LTTE lost it all by exploding a bomb in a bus at the Piliyandala bus station. The gruesome incident – in which 26 innocent civilians were killed and 38 injured – was a blatant act of terrorism.
Acts of terrorism in which innocent civilians are victimised must be condemned. This goes for acts of state terrorism also.
If the tigers had hoped to prove a point or two by the tenacious militaristic display at Muhamaalai , their brutal act of terrorism at Piliyandala turned the tables on them.
The LTTE strategy may have been to show that they were capable of inflicting a military defeat in the frontlines as well as infiltrate a Colombo suburb and plant a bomb but the end result was counter – productive.
[Buddhist monks stand at attention during the funeral of monk Vepathaira Chanananda at the cemetery in Piliyandala, a suburb of Colombo, April 29, 2008. Chanananda and another 25 people were killed in the suspected Tamil Tiger bomb explosion on a packed community bus-pic via Yahoo! News by Anuruddha Lokuhapuarachchi]
Both the national and international media publicised the pathetic plight of the civilian victims locally and abroad. Given the overwhelming international and national mood against terrorism the bus incident got more coverage than the battlefront debacle.
Had the LTTE refrained from the terrorist action of killing and injuring innocent civilians in a bus, the case of those arguing against the march of folly towards a military solution, could have gained more strength.
Once the LTTE exploded a bomb with terrible consequences the proponents of a political solution were effectively silenced.One cannot advocate political dialogue over military confrontation in the aftermath of a brutal terrorist attack.
A Colombo based diplomat told this columnist immediately after Muhamaalai about a tentative plan to meet President Rajapakse and emphasise the need to suspend war and promote peace talks. The move was aborted after the Piliyandala bomb.
” Our position on the need to suspend war and engage in talks still remains the same. The fighting in the north and the explosion in the south strengthen our stance that the solution can only be politically evolved and not militarily imposed. But timing is important in matters like these. Friday’s Piliyandala bombing has screwed up matters”, the diplomat said.
Despite the Muhamaalai debacle the Rajapakse regime’s hand has been strengthened further. There is very little pressure on the Government to call off the war.
To the contrary the hawkish sections in the corridors of power who had been dumbstruck after the Muhamaalai debacle have begun re-asserting themselves. More war seems to be on the agenda.
Each time the LTTE engages in an act of terrorism the hard-liners get re-invigorated.The underlying justice of the Tamil cause gets undermined.The terrible situation of the Tamil people is overlooked. The Tamil problem is easiliy distorted into a terrorist problem.
The LTTE plays into Colombo’s hands by such acts. The Government’s so called war against terrorism gains wider accptance. The peace doves are weakened. The battle hawks are strengthened.
Meanwhile Police sleuths investigating the April 25th bombing of the bus at Piliyandala claimed to have made a distinct breakthrough when they arrested three persons in connection with the incident. Two relatives of an arrested suspect are also being questioned.
According to informed sources two of those arrested were Tamils and the third a Sinhalese. One of those arrested is suspected of being a seasoned tiger operative. The Identity card in his possession says that his name is Lawrence David Raju. It is doubted whether that is really his name.
This man had allegedly placed the deadly bomb in the bus at Piliyandala bus station. He is known by the name “Appan” and has also used the names Prakash and Vasanthan.
The Sinhala accomplice who allegedly took “Appan” to the bus station is a 21 year old youth called Ranasinghe Aarachilage Buddhika.He is being interrogated intensively.
The third person arrested is also a Tamil who was residing at 210/2, Horana road, Piliyandala. The man named Devendran Siinnaiah has a brother Vijayendran Sinnaiah in Kilinochchi.
Vijayendran is a hard – core tiger and has been involved along with his brother Devendran in transporting LTTE cadre to Colombo and suburbs.Another brother Rajendran Sinnaiah is being held at the Negombo jail for a weapon related offence.
A fourth brother is a Police sergeant attached to the traffic division at Kollupitiya Police station. His wife is a woman Police inspector. Both are being questioned now.
Though investigations are still incomplete this columnist was informed by knowledgeable sources that two lines of inquiry are being pursued.
One is that of a “London link”. Apparently the attack was conceived of and co-ordinated by tiger bigwigs in Britain. The LTTE cell operating in Piliyandala was being handled via London it is suspected.
The modus operandi seems to have been that of “communication” between the Kilinochchi command and the Piliyandala cell being conducted by telephone via London.
It was only a few days ago that three persons aged 46, 39 and 33 were arrested in London by the British authorities for suspected LTTE links.
A high level Police delegation may leave for London shortly to pursue investigations regarding both the London link in the Piliyandala explosion as well as the tiger involvement of the trio recently arrested by the British police.
The second line of inquiry being pursued is whether the Piliyandala cell had originally intended to target in the Galkissa-Dehiwela area , a businessman named Kumar Rajapakse allegedly involved in the arms and armament dealings.
It is suspected that there was a sudden change of plan after the killing of the Catholic Priest cum human rights activist, Fr. Mariampillai Xavier Karunaratnam on April 20th in the LTTE controlled Wanni region.
Fr. Karunaratnam was targeted-at Ambaikulam between Vavunikulam and Vannivilankulam-through a claymore device in what was a deliberate killing perpetrated by a special assassination squad run by military intelligence.
While fighting continued between the security forces and LTTE along many fronts in the Mannar – Vavuniya area the spotlight has been shifting gradually to the Manal aaru-Weli-Oya region.
The Manal Aaru region comprises areas from the Mullaitheevu, Vavuniya, Anuradhapura and Trincomalee districts. Tamil inhabitants from 28 villages and 40 hamlets. farm settlements were driven out in the eighties of the last century in a flagrant exercise of ethnic cleansing by the United National Party regime under Junius Richard Jayewardena.
The region was then settled by Sinhala agriculturists and fisherfolk brought from different parts of the Country. A network of military camps was established to “protect” the new settlers many of whom were trained as home guards.
The area has been rapidly Sinhalaised with the ancient Tamil names being changed to Sinhala. Names like Mankindimalai, Kurunthumalai, Thannimurippu etc have gone out of use. There are new militarised settlements like Janakapura, Kalyanipura, Parakramapura etc.
Even streams and rivers known by their old Tamil names have been translated into Sinhala. Thus “Paalamai Odai” has become Kiri Iibban wewa. “Aanai Vizhulunthaan Aaru” is now called Ali wetuna wewa.
The process began in the eighties itself when Manal Aaru became Weli – Oya just as Kudumbimalai is now becoming Thoppigala.
The sad irony in this that both the Tamil and Sinhala names have the same meaning in many instances except where new militarized settlements have sprung up.
“Aanai vizhunthaan Aaru” and “ali wetuna wewa” for example mean in English “the river that the elephant fell in”. So too is Weli – Oya and Manal aaru meaning sandy river or stream.
The creation of Weli – Oya in the Manal Aaru region is a politico – military project. The ethnic cleansing of Tamil inhabitants along with the militarised Sinhalaisation of the region was a calculated scheme to interdict territorial contiguity between the Tamil dominated Northern province and Tamil majority Eastern province.
The Weli oya – Manal aaru region has seen an escalation of military activity in recent times. The 59 division under the command of Brig. Nandana Udawatte is stationed there.
The LTTE cadre drawn mainly from the Imran – Pandiyan infantry division and Sothiya womens brigade are stationed at the “Manal aaru kalamunai” (Weli oya battlefront) under the command of “Col” Balraj.
Balraj a former member of the Peoples Liberation Organization of Tamil Eelam (PLOTE) hails from Puthukudiyiruppu and is an original son of the Wani soil. He was at one time a protegee of ex – LTTE deputy leader Gopalswamy Mahendrarajah alias Mahattaya.
Balraj rose rapidly in the ranks and was responsible for early victories of the LTTE in Kokavil and Mankulam. He was made deputy military commander of the LTTE and played a crucial role in the war for Elephant pass in 2000.
“Col” Balraj led a sea – borne invasion that landed at Kudaarappu that made its way clandestinely to the A – 9 highway and interdicted supplies at Inthaavil between Elephant pass – Iyakkachchi and Eluthumadduvaal. This was the turning point which paved the way for the ultimate defeat.
Balraj who underwent severe injuries to his leg walks with a slight limp at times. He also underwent an operation in Colombo during the ceasefire.
In recent times two senior LTTE leaders “Col” Sornam and “Col” Bhanu have been sent to the Manal aaru/ Weli – Oya region to assist and supplement the efforts of “Col” Balraj.
The frontlines are about 12 km in length extending from Aanaivizhunthaan aaru in the interior to Kokuthoduvaai along the coast. An elaborate complex of military installations and forward defence lines have been set up along this 12 km line of control.
There have been many skirmishes and ” limited ” offensives by the armed forces in recent times. There has also been intermittent exchanges of artillery fire.
The army has also infiltrated into tiger territory in small groups and engaged the LTTE. The army has succeeded in injuring some tigers through landmines including a senior tiger leader.
Basically the 59 – 3 brigade has been active along the Kokuthoduvaai – Alambil front; the 59 – 2 has been active in the Naayaaru – Kumulamunai front; the 59 – 1 is concentrated along the Janakapura centered FDL’s.
Though not spectacular some significant advances have been made by the 59 into tiger territory. An area of about 4 1/2 to 5 km has been seized from the LTTE although the overall strategy at this juncture is not to acquire real estate.
The 59 division has been actively engaged in combat from January 1st this year. According to military reports the 59 division claims to have killed 537 LTTE cadre in the period between January 1st and April 30th.
It is also claimed that 653 tigers were injured during this period. The bodies of 47 LTTE cadre were recovered by the soldiers in these 4 months.
The LTTE however refutes the casualty figures claimed by the Army.
It is apparent that the strategic importance of this front is likely to cause increased military activity in the near future. The fact that LTTE supremo Velupillai Prabakharan has “transferred” two senior leaders Sornam and Bhanu from Mannar to Mullaitheevu denotes this fact.
“Col” Bhanu is in overall charge of the Kittu artillery corps as well as the “kutty Sri mortar unit. Both Kittu and Kutty Sri took their lives and sank with the LTTE ship “Ahad” on Jan 16th 1993 when surrounded by the Indian navy in international waters .
There has been a departure in the pattern of artillery-mortar fire after Bhanu moved in. Instead of targeting FDL positions alone as in the past the LTTE is now targeting the army’s area headquarter positions and field command posts also.
The tiger artillery shells have also fallen into civilian settlements like Parakramapura and Sinhapura. This has resulted in a minor exodus.
There has been a marked increase both quantitative and qualitative after “col” Bhanu entered the scene. On April 26th for instance a total of 37 shells were fired within a relatively short period. Six soldiers were killed and 13 injured.
The army gauged that the shells were being fired from a point in the Nedunkerny area. The army retaliated by using multi – barrel rocket launchers(MBRL).
It is not known whether the tiger artillery was hit but the Tamilnet claimed that two civilians, an elderly man and woman were injured in Nedunkerny.
The army however states that intercepts of radio messages reveal that 29 tigers were killed and 53 injured in the firing.
Military circles have noted with concern that there has been a conspicuous increase in artillery and mortar firing by the LTTE in the recent past.
At one point the LTTE was using its artillery and mortar very economically due to the difficulties it was facing in procuring regular supplies via sea. The Navy and Air Force had succeeded in circumscribing marine supply routes it was said.
However in recent times the LTTE has been very “liberal” in using mortars and artillery. Apart from using its home made “Ragavan” artillery shells and the mortar shells named Paseelan and Kumarappa the tigers have also been using “imported” stuff.
This is visible in multiple fronts in Mannar , Mullaitheevu and the Muhamaalai region.
Apparently the tigers have succeeded not only in getting a fresh supply of artillery and mortar shells but also have procured adequate “raw material” to manufacture their own varieties.
The induction of fresh supply of shells was confirmed in two recent intelligence reports.
The State Intelligence service in a report submitted to the Joint Operations Command stated that two LTTE ships had unloaded arms and other military related supplies on February 16th and 17th this year.
The vessels were stationed deep sea and the unloaded stuff was fetched to different points along the Vettrilaikerny-Challai coast by trawlers.A first hand account has been obtained from ” persons” who had purportedly been involved in carrying boxes.
In another report presented by the military intelligence division to the national security council it was said that another LTTE ship on March 28th had brought war materials, fuel , medicine etc from the Indian coast to Naachikuda along the Mannar coast.
The fact that three LTTE ships have reportedly broken through the naval cordon was not a pleasant fact to digest. There is also the possibility that more ships may have transported additional armaments and war material.
While the Navy is going on with its sea patrols focusing mainly on the Trincomalee – Mullaitheevu coast there has been visible lethargy in taking pro-active initiatives.
Some defence circles believe that the December 2007 incident of a Navy Fast – attack craft (FAC) being destroyed by the LTTE in the Neduntheevu seas, the February 2008 “seizure” of a naval water jet in the Thalaimannar seas and the recent demolition of another FAC through a submersible device in the Nayaaru seas have altogether had a cumulative effect on the Navy.
There is also the additional deterrent of explosive laden boats manned by “black sea tiger” suicide cadre accompanying LTTE flotilla. All this has led to a slackening of pro-active naval activity and has led to breaches in maritime naval cordons , it is felt.
There is also suspicion that the “international” support provided in curtailing LTTE maritime movement is not readily forthcoming as in the past. If correct, this may be related to growing international displeasure over the Gung Ho policies of the Rajapakse regime.
The LTTE also “scored ” politically when it re-activated its hibernating air wing described as the “Tamil Eelam Air Force”. Two small Ziln planes carrying three bombs each flew up from a clandestine airstrip along the Mullaitheevu coast.
They were targeting an MBRL artillery pad and a military headquarters complex in the Weli-oya /Manal Aaru region. Five of the six bombs exploded but failed to inflict large scale destruction.
Several buildings and six vehicles were damaged.
The important point however was the fact that the tiger planes were able to come from nowhere, drop bombs and return safely without any problem in spite of the elaborate air defence systems said to be in place.
It is said that a tiger helicopter was also scouring the skies simultaneously in what may have been either a diversionary tactic or aerial surveillance mission.
There have been a number of reports in the media about the air force having destroyed several LTTE airstrips and related installations. The latest attack shows that the tiger air wing is not merely alive and kicking but flying and dropping.
In a separate development the LTTE sustained a “cultural” loss when Subramaniam Kannan alias Major Silambarasan a.k.a. “Kuttikkannan” was killed in the fighting. Kuttikannan hailing from the Trincomalee district was a well – known singer of Tamil nationalist songs.
His most famous number was “Aandaandu Kaalamathaai” (for many, many years of our time) He was called Kuttikannan to differentiate between the senior musician Kannan and him. LTTE political commissar Balasingham Nadesan presided over the special funeral ceremony.
These then are the fluctuating fortunes of war. The bloodshed and mayhem goes on relentlessly . Even as the armed opponents pursue the illusion of a military solution the helpless civilians continue to bear the brunt.
DBS Jeyaraj can be reached on djeyaraj2005@yahoo.com
May 3rd, 2008