Click for News Update: tweetsTrove

PICTORIAL

CHR Sri Lanka images on LLRC sessions. Jaffna.

PICTORIAL

Breakfast at a cafe in Jaffna

transCurrents Home

Tamil Nadu Survey finds support for Tamil Eelam and LTTE but also for arresting its leader

The politics of the Tamil affairs in neighbouring Sri Lanka has always been a lightning rod in Tamil Nadu. It raises support and various sentiments across many spectrums of society.

Particularly, support for the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) has been controversial at best, since the assassination of Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi.

Nevertheless the general view has been that vast support for the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam stems only among a group of minor politicians of the Southern Indian State.

But a just-released survey by Ananda Vikatan, The popular Tamil weekly magazine of Tamil Nadu shows a small yet surprising comfortable majority (54.25 percent) of people in Tamil Nadu supporting the LTTE, while only 17.4 percent oppose it. 28.34 percent said they supported LTTE before the assassination of Indian Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi.

Ananda Vikatan commenced publishing in 1928 and it is an influential publishing powerhouse in Tamil Nadu today.

The weekly magazine has published the results of the survey on the August 8 issue.

The results of the survey is reported today in the website of the premier Tamil Daily of Sri Lanka, Virakesari.

The Survey also finds:

I. Tamil Eelam as a solution supported by 55.4%, Not needed 9.91% and for federal solution 34.63%

II. On LTTE ban, to continue 27.43%, lift the ban 47.65% also 24.91% wants to wait and see.

III. LTTE leader Pirapaharan, as accused in the assassination of Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi: 43.02% says LTTE leader should be arrested, 40.07% says he could be pardoned and 16.90% said did not commit the crime.

IV. On the measures for India to take regarding Sri Lanka, 62.59% said intervention a must to seek solution while 24.81 % said intervention needed only if the situation gets too severe. 12.58% of the respondents wanted India to stay out of the Sri Lanka situation.

V. On the matter of Katchatheevu, suddenly in the forefront of affairs across the Palk Straits, 65.76% said India must retake control and 27.96% said at least rights to go to the island must be fully restored. 6.26% said the matter needs no attention now.

The details of the opinion poll appeared in Ananda Vikatan as reported in TamilNet:

1.On their stand on LTTE...
  Votes Percentage
Always support 2,276 54.25
Always against 730 17.40
Supported before the assassination of Rajiv Gandhi 1,189 28.34
2. On forming an independent Thamizh Eezham...
  Votes Percentage
Correct solution 2,326 55.44
Not necessary 416 9.91
Self rule for Tamils should be sufficient 1,453 34.63
3.On the Indian government ban on LTTE...
  Votes Percentage
Correct stand 1,151 27.43
The ban should be removed 1,999 47.65
Should wait and see 1,045 24.91
4.On the Tamil Nadu leaders’ (Vaiko, Ramadoss, Thirumalavan, Nedumaran) support for LTTE...
  Votes Percentage
Correct stand 2,071 49.36
Dangerous policy 571 13.61
It's for other agenda 1,553 37.02
5.On LTTE leader Pirapaharan who is accused of involvement in the assassination of Rajiv Gandhi...
  Votes Percentage
Should be arrested 1,805 43.02
Is innocent 709 16.90
Should be forgiven 1,681 40.07
6.On what should be done by India in the Sri Lankan crisis...
  Votes Percentage
India should not get involved 528 12.58
India should involve to find a solution 2,626 62.59
India should only get involved if the conflict gets out of control 1,041 24.81
7.On LTTE assassinating Tamil politicians of dissenting views...
  Votes Percentage
Cannot be accepted at all 1,810 43.14
Inevitable approach 1,089 25.95
Do not understand the circumstances there 1,296 30.89
8.On LTTE growing to possess a standing army, navy and air force...
  Votes Percentage
A matter to be proud of 1,940 46.24
A danger to India 780 18.59
Neither of the above 1,475 35.16
9.On ruling DMK’s (Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam) stand on LTTE...
  Votes Percentage
DMK should take a harder stand against LTTE 953 22.71
DMK should support LTTE without worrying about being in power 1,992 47.48
DMK may continue its current policy of apathy. 1,250 29.79
10. On Nalini’s (convicted in Rajiv Gandhi assassination) continued imprisonment even after completion of sentence...
  Votes Percentage
Nalini should be released 1,747 41.64
She may be released and kept under supervision 1,579 37.64
Her imprisonment should continue 869 20.71
11. On the islet of Kachchatheevu...
  Votes Percentage
India should retrieve Kachchatheevu from Sri Lanka 2,759 65.76
India may give up Kachchatheevu 263 6.26
India should at least have assert to the rights of Indians getting access to Kachchatheevu. 1173 27.96
12. On the issue of Indian fishermen, getting killed by the Sri Lankan navy...
  Votes Percentage
India should respond with military force 1,244 29.65
India should resolve the issue through negotiations 1,464 34.89
India should severely reprimand Sri Lanka in the international arena 1,487 35.44

16 Comments

It will be very hard now to stop this war turning into a Sinhalese vs Tamils(TN + Kerala + Eelam + Eelam Diaspora + everywhere Tamils lives) war now - the more Tamils all over the worls see their brothers and sisters live under trees due to the Sinhalese war machine.

The issue now is - The North Indians have the Pakistanis- now the South will have the Sinhalese.

It will be interesting to see where ceratain Eelam Tamils ( Karuna, Pilayan etc) who has helped the Sinhalese in the war against the their brothers now stand.

Everybody will soon or later have to take side? But where do traitors stand?

For the Sinhalese, I donot get it - the South (of India) is the fastest growing economy in the world - and they decided to become the sworn enemy of the people now driving the economy of the South of India. Wars does not have to be fought just on the battlefield - economic warfare is just as painful and inhumane. Most people in TN and kerala are proud of the LTTE as a fighting force - so this unit will be there to stay as long as South India wants it to bleed the Sinhalese slowly, just to keep the wound from healing, and to remind them of the debt of Black July.

Guest who will be the last man standing in 500 years?

From an independent observer. - snpost

Posted by: snpost | August 2, 2008 05:27 PM

The survey was by Ananda Vikedan - or in English is Happy Joker. How credible is their survey - anton

Posted by: anton | August 2, 2008 06:27 PM

Very honestly the Tamilnadu people have given their opinion.

It looks like if LTTE led by somebody else will be supported very well by the Tamilnadu people. Only Vaico could tie the bell on the cat's neck.

By - Selva

Posted by: Selva | August 2, 2008 06:46 PM

Hysterical...Who cares what Tamil Nadu think????

At the end of the day, all these polls mean nothing as it is not up to them about the affairs of Sri Lanka. Tamil Nadu while are Tamils ... are not Sri Lankans... End of Discussion. - Devinda Fernando

Posted by: Devinda Fernando | August 2, 2008 10:58 PM

The survey had showed democracy, or the wish of the Tamil people been laid in the open. Knowing Tamil politicians Tamil Eelam will be a point in central New Delhi theme either via DMK or MDMK after general election.

As of now DMK will call the shot due to survival life line of Congress. Gotto wait and see because all are not decided at war front. Looks like Tigers will be back in businesss by early next year. Till then we will poor and innocent Sinhalese soldiers dying for their monthly wages. - k kalaiy

Posted by: Anonymous | August 3, 2008 11:14 AM

[devinda wrote:Hysterical...Who cares what Tamil Nadu thinks?] u may not like what Tamil nadu thinks, but u should care.

In fact i suspect u did care, when u thought they were totally against tamil eelam and the ltte, until now. - eesan

Posted by: eesan | August 3, 2008 10:13 PM

The Tamils of Tamil Nadu state have studied the history of genocide of Tamils in Sri Lanka with a Tamil mindset.

Post colonial history of our island has unambiguously recorded that Colombo had been the symbol of deception, dishonesty, trickery and unwillingness to implement agreements and legislation to grant rights to Tamils.

Appropriate attitude and actions are vital for successful completion of any peace talks anywhere in the world. Because of three main political reasons it would be impossible for any sensible person to believe that an appropriate climate now exists in Sri Lanka (SL) for successful peace talks leading to peace.

Firstly, the majority of Sinhala politicos and the populace are not yet educated enough to respect the legitimate right of Tamils to rule themselves in the North East (NE).

Secondly, Most of the Sinhalese have arrogantly fallen in a collective swoon for war in the NE. Trapped in the war, they have defiantly turned their back on the UN and the International Community, instead of partnering with them to obtain valuable expertise, to successfully hold peace talks to completion and implementation.

Thirdly, rather than regard the TNA and the LTTE as threat to the island, the present GOSL should have recognised that working with them would solve the Tamil problem.

Such realisation was absent before trumpeting for war in the NE and abrogating the CFA with flimsy excuses.

All these happened because true political leadership, visualising the future good of all the citizens ceased to exist in 1956. To this day, there is no leader capable of solving any island wide political problem affecting the rights and freedoms of all the citizens. All peace talks failed since 1956 for this reason.

On the other side of the continuum, for the majority of Tamils and the UN, peace talks is a less appealing proposal than justice for human rights violations and war crimes.

Under Mahinda Rajapakse's watch, his soldiers were beating, bombing, raping, torturing, arresting, disappearing, displacing and murdering Tamils in the NE.

The nature of rights violations and the techniques employed by the soldiers in the NE make Radovan Karadzic of Bosnia look like a good guy.

For Tamils in the NE, the human rights violations represent dead loved ones and nightmares that will always haunt them. The incidents are leaving irreparable scar in their minds, preventing them from seeing ahead anything other than Tamil Eelam.

Though the underlying philosophy of democracy is justice, state interference in favour of the crimes of soldiers has made judicial process non existent for war crimes in the NE.

Peace and reconciliation are possible only through the filter of justice. As internal justice is impossible in the NE, we should request the UN to send Human Rights Monitors to report incidents of "no justice", if we desire human dignity and peace to all in our island. - Sam Thambipillai

Posted by: Sam Thambipillai | August 4, 2008 09:43 AM

Mr. Thambipillai

Firstly, the majority of Sinhala politicos and the populace don’t believe in the concept of a mono-ethnic state encompassing more than a third of the country ruled by a murdering cult god claiming to represent 10% of the population. The majority, unlike the thugs who perpetrate ethnic violence, want to live with their neighbors of may races like they do in Kandy and Colombo. They are not ready to hand over a large part of the country to a small sect of Tamils while the majority of Tamils live with them in the rest of the country

Secondly, Most of the Sinhalese have meekly realized that the only option is to eliminate the LTTE and open a window for a negotiated settlement. After a series of attempts at negotiations, the Sinhala and their democratically elected representatives have realized that the LTTE a. does not represent the people they claim to, and b. don’t give a hoot about anything else but war. There can never be peace as long as the LTTE exists in its current form with its current leader.

Thirdly, the Sri Lanka Monitoring Mission recorded 3006 violations of the ceasefire by the LTTE compared to the 174 violations by the government. So who abrogated what ceasefire?

Posted by: Chaminda | August 5, 2008 04:56 AM

People of Tamilnadu are important stakeholders of Sri Lankan conflict. That's because they are the immediate neighbours of Sri lanka who face consequences of unrest in the neighbourhood. (Last year I went to Chennai and experienced that hotel workers out there looks suspiciously at Sri Lankans.)The other reason is their Tamil Nationalist sentiments.

(I mean the natural feeling towards the peope of your race)

It is unfortunate that real leaders of Tamilnadu (not the people like Vaiko who are in LTTE payroll) nor the Govt. of Sri Lanka are directly talking to each other without North Indian mediadion. This communication gap has a negative impact towards the resolution of SL conflict.

As far as above survey is concerned, I am surpriced that only 54% supported LTTE. I thought there is overwhelming support for LTTE in TN. Nobody can say that the TN public support towards LTTE has increased based on this survey without a referance to historical figures.

BUT When I see comments like that of 'snpost' I feel glad that Rajapakse govt. is mercilessy fighting LTTE & I also feel glad that TN is under N.Indian supervision. I am also glad that people like 'snpost' have apparently fled Sri Lanka, such that after LTTE, we will have to live with Tamils who know the futility of violent methods to achieve political goals.

Posted by: Harsha | August 5, 2008 05:41 AM

*** when u thought they were totally against tamil eelam and the ltte, until now. - eesan ***

And what are the Tamil Naduians going to do about it?

I specifically care about India, and what they think, and if they were for Eelam I would disagree and would be part of the Majority who would oppose their political agenda... but the reality is that Tamil Nadu like all the Politicians there are one big Joke... they don't really care beyond the opinion poll level about the Tamils of the North or the LTTE...they support them as they do a Sports team. They are at the end of the day not committed to supporting Eelam.

All these Tamil Nadu politicians use The LTTE issue as a way to rally their voter bases, but they can't do anything more than make noise for the LTTE... At the end of the day India's foreign Policy will never allow Eelam,...Especially after Rajiv Gandhi's assasination. This is the Truth, the Whole Truth, and nothing but the Truth...

So help me (Sun) GOD.

Posted by: Devinda Fernando | August 5, 2008 01:06 PM

chaminda wrote: "Thirdly, the Sri Lanka Monitoring Mission recorded 3006 violations of the ceasefire by the LTTE compared to the 174 violations by the government. So who abrogated what ceasefire?"

"One" of those "174" violations by the GOSL side was: not implementing the agreement to allow back the more than 90,000 people to return to their homes and livelihood in the HSZs.

Most of the houses in the HSZs, btw, have been flattened by the army. So, it would hardly have sufficed to merely allow back these displaced people to the lands where their homes once stood, but it would have at-least been a start.

This one violation is equivalent to 90,000 violations.... PER DAY. The GOSL wants you to count that as one violation.

So, "What ceasefire?" indeed!

Posted by: eesan | August 7, 2008 11:09 AM

Devinda Fernando wrote: "And what are the Tamil Naduians going to do about it?"

You may be right, possibly nothing. But I want to point out this was precisely the attitude of the GOSL and the chauvinists among the Sinhalese when they inflicted riots and other methods of intimidation in response to peaceful representations by the Tamils. They thought: " What can the Tamils do about it?".

Another mistake would be to consider India to be a big constant in the formula in your head. At the end of the day the only "territorial integrity" that India cares about, is its own.

Posted by: eesan | August 7, 2008 11:53 AM

Chaminda wrote "Thirdly, the Sri Lanka Monitoring Mission recorded 3006 violations of the ceasefire by the LTTE compared to the 174 violations by the government. So who abrogated what ceasefire?"

3006 complaints not violations. It was never proven so it cannot be regarded as violations. Get the facts right.

Posted by: Thamilan | August 8, 2008 12:03 PM

I cannot believe it

Posted by: sam | August 11, 2008 11:31 PM

Hi Folks in all this discussion you are forgetting one person who is watching the fun and going to bank laughing to deposit the money he has got. You guessed it right. That's Ananda Vikaden. All this survey is humbug. LTTE is a closed chapter.

Posted by: k Stephen | August 26, 2008 07:59 AM

Your survey is very real data and reflaction of the tmail people.
Thank you,
Solution of the war when the freedom of Tamil Eelam and take over the Eelam Government by LTTE

Posted by: Ulaganathan.s | February 18, 2009 07:51 AM

Post a comment

(The comment may need to be approved by transcurrents.com. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting; generally approved/posted if they are not abusive of the topic as well as the author and/or another commenter.)

(Please write the comment in paragraphs if its long and allow space between paragraphs, for easier reading by others)

Recent Posts on TC