Protect Civilians in ‘Final’ Attack
UN Security Council Should Initiate Commission of Inquiry
(New York, April 20, 2009) – An expected major attack following the Sri Lankan government’s “final warning” to the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam underscores the need for heightened measures to minimize civilian casualties, Human Rights Watch said today. The continuing laws of war violations by both the Sri Lankan army and the LTTE indicate the need for a United Nations commission of inquiry to investigate war crimes by both sides, Human Rights Watch said.
Sources in the 20-square-kilometer “no-fire zone” reported to Human Rights Watch that the Sri Lankan army is still using heavy artillery in attacks on the densely populated area and that the LTTE continues to block civilians from fleeing. There were unconfirmed reports of hundreds of civilian casualties today alone. At least 10,000 people have managed to escape in the past day, but 50,000 to 100,000 civilians remain in the conflict area under grave threat.
“The government’s ‘final warning’ to the Tamil Tigers should not be considered a final warning to the thousands of trapped civilians,” said Brad Adams, Asia director at Human Rights Watch. “Both sides need to show far greater concern for civilians, or many more civilians will die.”
Under international humanitarian law applicable to the armed conflict in Sri Lanka, both the Sri Lankan armed forces and the LTTE are obligated to take all feasible precautions to minimize harm to civilian life and property. But since January, both sides have shown little regard for the safety of civilians in the embattled Vanni region in northeastern Sri Lanka, and more than 4,500 civilians are believed to have died in the fighting, according to UN estimates. The LTTE has violated the laws of war by using civilians as “human shields,” by preventing civilians from fleeing the combat zone, and by deliberately deploying their forces close to densely populated civilian areas. The Sri Lankan armed forces have indiscriminately shelled densely populated areas, including hospitals, in violation of the laws of war.
Human Rights Watch reminded Sri Lanka of its obligations under international law to investigate credible allegations of war crimes, including by members of its own forces, and appropriately prosecuting those responsible. Past Sri Lankan government investigations into allegations of war crimes have led to few prosecutions, particularly in recent years. Human Rights Watch also called on the UN Security Council to establish a Commission of Inquiry into allegations of war crimes by both sides.
“The Sri Lankan government needs to hear loudly and clearly from a concerted international community that they, just as the Tamil Tigers, will be held accountable for what happens to the civilians in the no-fire zone,” said Adams. “It is high time for the humanitarian crisis in Sri Lanka to be officially taken up on the Security Council's agenda.”
Individuals who commit serious violations of international humanitarian law with criminal intent – that is, deliberately or recklessly – should be prosecuted for war crimes, Human Rights Watch said. War crimes include using human shields and deliberately attacking civilians. Evidence as to whether indiscriminate attacks on civilians were deliberate or reckless would include information on the known number of civilians in the area under attack, attacks striking presumptively civilian objects such as hospitals, and a showing that such attacks occurred repeatedly.
In addition to those who ordered or executed unlawful actions or attacks, commanders who knew or should have known of war crimes being committed and failed to take measures to stop them can be held responsible as a matter of command responsibility.
“Military commanders on both sides need to be taking civilian security into account in every action they take,” said Adams. “By not doing so, they are leaving themselves open to future investigations and prosecution.”
To view “Sri Lanka: Trapped and Under Fire,” an audio slideshow on the civilians affected by fighting in the Vanni region in northeastern Sri Lanka, please visit:
http://www.hrw.org/en/features/sri-lanka-trapped-and-under-fire
For more of Human Rights Watch’s work on Sri Lanka, please visit:
http://www.hrw.org/en/asia/sri-lanka
For more information, please contact:
In London, Brad Adams (English): +44-20-7713-2767; or +44-790-872-8333 (mobile)
In New York, Anna Neistat (English, Russian): +1-212-377-9491; or +1-443-812-9640 (mobile)
In Mumbai, Meenakshi Ganguly (English, Hindi, Bengali): +91-982-003-6032 (mobile)


7 Comments
I think the HRW can prepare multiple cases for the Hague. That is the only possoble step left for them.
" A predicted case with predicted results but no one came forward to prevent except serving WORD SOUP"
"We are deeply concern”
“We are worried about the situation”
“We urged to protect”
“A Looming bloodbath is real in the beach"
Will see you all in Hague
A bit strong with their comments now! But have they got the teeth to bite? If so they could have shown it earlier! Still, why are they cautioning the Tigers when they know well that the lives of the civilians are in the hands of the GoSL?
When are we going to see a war crimes trial of those who firebombed Dresden, who flattened Ben Tre and who butchered the civilians of My Lai?
In what way is this situation different to a Berlin surrounded by the Allies? Why did the allies not halt the offensive at the city walls to avoid harming the civilians?
"An expected major attack following the Sri Lankan government’s “final warning” to the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam underscores the need for heightened measures to minimize civilian casualties, Human Rights Watch said today."
Isn't it funny that we have so many willing to be umpire's of this war? All trying to teach the warring parties how to fight... and how to behave...? Even at this point where there is ample evidence that the government forces are operating with the best of the civilians in mind? Has there been any carpet bombings? Napalm showers?
Rather than just being critical of the SL armed forces, (at this point when they are holding the upper hand and when it is clear that it is the LTTE that prevents civilians from getting out of the warzone) wouldn't it be wiser and more productive to ask the SL government what assistance it needs to safely remove trapped civilians from the midst of the war zone?
This kind of double tonguing would only serve to justify LTTE's blackmailing of the world.
Think it's a bit too late - the final battle is already on and it will stop sooner than later when LTTE is wiped out of Sri Lanka. The GOSL will not care much for what the Diaspora has to say cause the Tamils living in the country do not have an issue living in harmony with other nationalities.
If anyone reading saw Al Jazeera news today morning would have realized how badly the LTTE treated the people they held hostage. Including not feeding them or even giving a bit of water. How the LTTE shot at those who were trying to escape. LTTE is a Menace. Eliminated sooner the better for all in SL and world over.
If Hitler surrounded all the natzy sympathising Germans as a human shield, What would US and UK army do? would they talk of a ceasefire? Read about the Dresden, How UK firebombed it. Did US/UK think about the human casualties when it bombed Japan, Iraq.
Who investigated these allegations after the war? what commission? Winners wrote the history, I heard.
Sri Lankan government is doing their best to save the civilions and it is fact and not like tamilnet fairy tales.
Yes Janaka knows the truth!!! Do not allow any journalsit or UN - it is bad to for them to see the innocent civilians under brutal attack.
Time will come when you will feel sorry for the atrocities committed!
It is not now, but for fifty years - surely not forgotten already?