‘Boat People’ Recount Horrors of No-Fire Zone
UN Security Council and Human Rights Council Need to Take Urgent Action
(Kakinada, India, May 6, 2009) – Horrific accounts from refugees fleeing the fighting in Sri Lanka by boat show the wanton disregard for civilians of both Sri Lankan government forces and the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE), Human Rights Watch said today. Human Rights Watch called on both the United Nations Security Council and the UN Human Rights Council to make the situation in Sri Lanka a priority to avoid further loss of civilian life.
[M. Aruldas played with his 8-month-old nephew, Kuberan, as they recovered in a government hospital in Kakinada, India, on Monday, after drifting on a boat for nine days with other Sri Lankan refugees-pic: NY Times.com]
"The Sri Lankan government is doing everything it can to keep these stories of suffering from reaching the world," said Meenakshi Ganguly, senior Asia researcher at Human Rights Watch. "These accounts must be multiplied tens of thousands of times to capture the full horror of those who remain trapped by the Tamil Tigers and shelled by government forces."
Human Rights Watch interviewed a group of Sri Lankan refugees in Andhra Pradesh in India. The refugees were rescued on April 29, 2009, from Indian waters, where they had been lost at sea for nine days after fleeing from the government declared "no-fire zone" in northern Sri Lanka's Mullaitivu district. Accounts by refugees are especially important because the Sri Lankan government has long refused independent access to the combat zone for journalists and human rights monitors. The refugees' detailed statements contradict claims by the government that it is not using heavy weapons in the "no-fire zone."
A motorbike taxi driver, S. Indra Kumar, told Human Rights Watch that his family went to Putumattalan, on the coast, after the Sri Lankan government declared the area a safe zone: "We were living in such fear. There was constant shelling. On April 5 or 6, our neighbors were injured in the shelling. A shell landed inside the bunker. Ten people were injured, and of them, five died. There was no anesthesia. The doctors had to cut off a girl's hand without any anesthesia. My small daughter was crying and scared. I decided then that we had to leave."
He said that sometimes the shelling lasted so long that people could not come out to use the toilets: "Whenever there was shelling, we were in the bunker. There was heavy shelling, and the people were easing themselves in the bunker. I would take a bucket to clean up the mess and bury it in the sand."

[A 25-year-old former computer student, S. Indra Meenan, drifted on a boat for nine days with other Sri Lankan refugees. © 2009 Courtesy of Ruth Fremson/The New York Times]
His brother, S. Indra Meenan, a 25-year-old hardware engineer, described long periods of shelling: "In the village, every house had a bunker. Five or six people sitting inside, sometimes for three or four hours." He said that the Tamil Tigers sometimes fired from areas close to where the civilians were living, putting them at risk from retaliatory fire. "We left [by boat] on April 20 because we were scared. There was so much bombing and shelling. Every day, at least three or four hours, there was shelling. The firing was coming from the Sri Lankan army."
A mason, Sivadasa Jagdeshwaran, whose wife and 4-year-old son died on the boat journey to India, described his family's ordeal: "In the beginning, before we came to the safe zone, the government hospital was still there. My wife just had a baby, so she needed medicine. But there was no medicine at the hospital. I waited a whole day for medicines.
"The ICRC [International Committee of the Red Cross] was giving tents, but they could not cope with the demand. We built a shelter with coconut thatch. And when it rained or there was shelling, we ran to the bunker. There was shortage of food. One day, I was waiting in queue for food and there was suddenly shelling. I ran away, but later heard that 40 people had died."
Jagdeshwaran described trying to bury his father, who was hit by a shell in the safe area when he was riding his bicycle: "Many people have died. Whenever they heard there were bodies, they would collect for burial. Two months ago, my father went missing. I went to the hospital to look for my father. I found his body. The entire back of his head was missing. Only his face was there. We asked the doctor to do something to his head so we could bury him, but they said we should just be grateful that we had a body to bury."
The refugees described conditions along the sandy coastal strip where the fighting currently is ongoing. Some were able to use tents provided by the ICRC, while others huddled into makeshift shacks made of sheets and coconut fronds. They found it difficult to dig bunkers into sand. Some of those who had boats buried them in the sand to provide a base, and then created a roof of coconut tree logs and leaves. This was the only protection they had from the shelling. They also described shortages of food and medicine. S. Indra Kumar, the motorbike taxi driver, said: "The government was sending some grain. But if the need was for 100 kilos, they were sending 25 kilos. There were no NGOs [nongovernmental organizations], no medicines inside."
The refugees detailed to Human Rights Watch their harrowing journeys by boat to India, in which many died. The boat owner, Mariyada Yesudas, whose father, sister, nephew and two brothers and his uncle, the captain of the boat, died during the journey, said they felt they had no choice but to leave the safe area: "The army was really close. The LTTE was also very close. We thought the fighting had reached us. So we decided to leave before it was too late ... The army is very powerful and the LTTE was running away. How could it be safe for us?"
The accounts show the urgent need for safe humanitarian corridors for civilians to flee the fighting.
S. Indra Meenan, the hardware engineer, said: "We left at night when the shelling stopped. We were 21 people. No one saw our boat. Not the LTTE, not the army. No one tried to stop us. The boat driver had said that he would take enough food and water for us."
He said that the boat driver told them the trip to India would take nine hours. But they got lost, the motor stopped running and they ran out of fuel. They just drifted until they ran out of food and water: "We were drinking salt water. One by one, the people started dying. First it was the children. My brother's little daughter died."
Jagdeshwaran, the mason, told Human Rights Watch about the journey by boat that included his wife and two children and his wife's relatives: "My son died on April 24, four days after getting on the boat. He was 4 years old. We had no water, no food on the boat. Then her father died. Her two brothers jumped into the sea. My wife was in shock. She was weak and not even able to move. That morning, April 29, she asked for some water. We gave her seawater. She vomited and then she passed away."
Their 8-month-old son, having been fed on breast milk until his mother's death, survived.
Human Rights Watch called on the UN Human Rights Council in Geneva to hold a special session on the current situation in Sri Lanka. Human Rights Watch also reiterated its call for the UN Security Council to place Sri Lanka on its agenda and to create a commission of inquiry to investigate violations of international humanitarian law by both sides.
"While the Human Rights Council has sat on its hands, the Security Council has repeatedly failed to discuss Sri Lanka in a way that would permit even the mildest action," said Ganguly. "Given the gravity of the situation, both UN bodies need to come to grips with the scale of the disaster."
Related: Sri Lankans, Seeking Safety, Perish, By Somini Sengupta



8 Comments
Is there any wonder that these people prefered take a risk and take the boat ride to India than living in the "concentration camps" guarded by murderers and rapists? Please see the following clip. Shame!!
http://www.channel4.com/news/articles/politics/international_politics/grim+scenes+at+sri+lankan+camps+/3126257
It is a shame on UN security council particualarly China and Russia. Because they do not care how amny Tamils die they consider the problem as an internal problem of Srilanka. Even Japan and India are not keen it to be part of the UN agenda. Imagine if all these Asian powers who controld their minorities and keep them as second class, become more powerful than the US as a world police. Now China has thrown in One Million aid direct to Sinhala Government to help the IDPs in the North.Mahinda brothers and the Sinhalese armies and the Tamil & Muslim quislingswill decide what to do with that money or they will take a lion share as there is no media freedom or independentt observers.
Tamil Civilians who were mainly self sufficent farmers or farm workers or fishermen have been made homeless in the traditional habitats and moved away to barbed wire camps and have to beg for food, health and clothes.
Still the Mahinda's Sinhalese led government is democratic state plyer who has banned media and U N observers and are supported in the UN by countries like China, Russia, Japan, India, Libya, Iran. Imagine a world where China ,Russia, India and Iran become more powerful ?
How did these people managed to escape from the clutches of Tigers without their knowledge. I do not believe their stories. They are Tiger agents or Mahaveer families escaped with the help of Tamil Tigers to spread stories about Srilankan armed forces to discredit them.
Today in Afganistan dozen of civilians killed by US air strikes. HRW keep deepen silence over these incidents happening in that region.It is a disgrace.
It is time to be impartial HRW.Go and criticise your Masters and leave our forces to complete the mission of unite our country.
We would like to tell you that our forces are better human than barberic forces of West.
According to Richard Dixon a British national who had written an article about the suffering and deaths of innocent civilians in the war ravaged Winni in the Northern Srilanka. I quote below only the important aspect of his article for the world to know the seriousness of this unwanted war that is been fought by the Terrorist Government of Sri Lanka and the rebels who want to create a independent state so that every single Tamil men, women and Children could live in peace with out any harassment from the armed forces of the so called democratic republic of Sri Lanka. Headed by a ruthless and blood thirsty man called Mahinda R and his brothers. Here is the main part of the article released by Mr. Richard Dixon.
A Paradise turned into Kingdom of Vultures!
Monday, May 4, 2009, 05:34 PM GMT [General]
Sri Lanka: A Paradise turned into Kingdom of Vultures!
By Richard Dixon RichardDixons@googlemail.com
Land that was known for beautiful beaches and waterfalls has now been turned into a Kingdom of Vultures.
Dead bodies of the innocent Tamils are dragged away by stray dogs and wild beasts while the survivors hide inside the bunkers.
Let the dead bury the dead as the living will be dead if they try to bury the dead. Screams of the innocents can't be heard to the far away lands because the rulers of Sri Lanka are not even allowing the birds in the sky to carry the messages to the lands of the living.
Mothers cuddle their crying babies and hide in the bunkers all day long. Starving mothers don't have anything to give for their children. Frightened parents wipe their tears and pretend to be strong in order to comfort their children who are tormented by the demons of war.
Food and medicine are denied for the innocents and many of them are forced into starvation.
Most of the wounded are let to die in the open fields. Those who are fortunate enough to make to the make shift hospitals have their limbs amputated without anesthesia. Caesarian operations are carried out without pain relievers.
Chinese F7s and Russian MIG fighters fly over the skies of Wanni continuously and they regularly bomb hospitals, schools, churches and orphanages. Cluster bombs and phosphorous bombs are used against innocent Tamil civilians.
Children are dying in front of their parents and the parents are dying in front of their children. Many of the dead have nobody to mourn for them. More than eight thousand innocent Tamils have been killed just within the last three months.
Tamils are now left with nothing. All their homes and farm lands have been made into grave yards. Many families have lost their loved ones. Thousands of orphans and widows are longing for death than suffering from hunger and untreated wounds in the killing fields of Sri Lanka. They have no more comforters left to comfort the victims.
Well said Meenakshi Ganguly.
"While the Human Rights Council has sat on its hands, the Security Council has repeatedly failed to discuss Sri Lanka in a way that would permit even the mildest action," said Ganguly. "Given the gravity of the situation, both UN bodies need to come to grips with the scale of the disaster."
We can only hope at this juncture that the international community views Tamils as part of the human race too.
Sinhalese don't really know what has been happening in north and east. They believe what they read in pro government news papers. I can remember those days I stayed in the bunker for more than 5 hours due to the shelling from the army camp in Jaffna fort and pallali. Even after many years it still hurts. Sri Lankan government pushed us to support tigers without any choice. Little support and recognition from the government would have turned majority of middle class tamils against tigers.
Please visit Jaffna. you cane see lands and houses were bull dozed for miles from Pallali camp.
This incident clearly shows that people in NFZ are scared of surrendring/moving to GOSL areas, but are prepared to take big risks in leaky boats to move to safety guranteed in places like India.