Click for News Update: tweetsTrove

transCurrents Home

Monsoon Miseries of Manik Farm Complex IDPs

by Col.R.Hariharan

The Menik Farm complex and its temporary shelters, showcased last month as model for camps for people displaced due to the war, has become camps of misery for the residents as monsoon rains are lashing the area.

CHTC0818.jpg

[Internally displaced ethnic Tamil civilians wave to passersby at Manik Farm, a camp for the internally displaced in Vavuniya, about 230 Kilometers (144 miles) northeast of Colombo, Sri Lanka, Saturday, Aug. 15, 2009-AP pic]

Sri Lanka media of all shades of opinion have highlighted the terrible conditions created by incessant monsoon rains particularly in camp 2 and camp 4. Tents and temporary shelters are down or collapsed making them unliveable. Some camps do not have access to even water supply. Cooking is not possible and cooked food is not reaching the needy. Toilets are choked or busted. Storm drainage is either not existing or flooded. “As rain waters filled with sewage matter, maggots and human excreta rose in tents sheltering some 20,000 IDPs” is one description of the condition from the media.

And apparently the local administration and the NGOs working at these camps find the task of providing relief to those beleaguered in the flooded camps beyond their limited capability. And monsoon season is not yet over. The logical sequence of the tragedy would be outbreak of epidemic diseases like gastro enteritis striking the affected people. Another hidden danger is that land mines tend to get shifted due to flooding.

Everyone knew this was waiting to happen; monsoon rains have a pre-ordained regularity about them. The NGOs and the media spoke and wrote about it. The authorities and humanitarian agencies, who sited some of the camps in low lying areas, also knew the area was prone to flooding during the monsoon rains. Yet they went ahead and created the camps probably because they did not expect the residents of these camps to be stationed there indefinitely. Probably they were situated as they were for ensuring better physical security than any other reason.

In June itself the government had said the UN agencies were responsible for construction of drainage systems and flood preventive measures at the camp sites. So it was not surprising when the Minister of Resettlement and Disaster Management, Rizad Bathiudeen put the blame on them now.

He said “The UN agencies involved in the IDP camps had taken the responsibility of constructing the drainage systems and flood preventive measures. So the Government cannot be blamed for the poor condition of the drainage systems which burst and failed.” But the issue is not who is to be blamed, but providing relief to the affected people.

Unfortunately this simple truth appears to have been forgotten as the release of civilians has become a political issue. The opposition United National Party (UNP) leader Ranil Wickremesinghe recently asked the government to expedite the release of civilians held in these camps and inform parliament of the steps taken in this respect. The UNP leaders had strongly criticized the government for detaining innocent people.

And in his hard hitting repartee, Defence Secretary Gotabaya Rajapaksa had a different take. He accused the opposition of playing politics in what was essentially a national security issue. He highlighted the danger of LTTE operatives living amidst the IDPs in camps. He also pointed out the problem that could be posed if they gain access to the arms and explosives hidden in Vanni.

This aspect cannot be ignored by the government as arms and military equipment caches of LTTE are being unearthed almost everyday and quite a few investigations have been taken up to uncover LTTE’s support network among civilians. But at the same time, the government has an obligation for the welfare of civilians at large. It is not clear how the release of pregnant women, small children and the aged would compromise security. Their continued stay in camps would be only an exercise in humiliating a population that was in the wrong place at the wrong time.
It is clear the Sri Lanka government has suborned all other issues to the continued war against the LTTE.

Unfortunately, the humanitarian issues have become casualties in this mix up of priorities. And politicisation of the issue has further messed up action.

A delegation of concerned citizens including Mangala Samaraweera, MP and leader of the breakaway group of the Sri Lanka Freedom Party (SLFP) recently met the Indian External Affairs Minister SM Krishna and made a representation regarding the IDPs. The group sought India to pressurize the Sri Lanka government to demilitarize the camp administration and the rehabilitation process.

It is not clear what action New Delhi has taken on the subject of IDPs. They are likely to continue their stay camps well beyond six months. Indian High Commissioner’s message in Colombo on the occasion of the Independence Day conveyed to Sri Lanka that a "broad-based political settlement" of the ethnic conflict would enable the Rs.500-crore relief, reconstruction and rehabilitation package for the nearly three lakh war displaced to be utilised in a more effective and efficient manner.

Does this mean the relief and reconstruction package would come into play when a broad based political settlement is made? Given the political developments in Sri Lanka, India might have to wait a long time for that to happen.

In the meanwhile, what about the IDPs plight? Human dignity is beyond mere supply of relief and construction materials. Will some of our worthy parliament members, who spoke eloquently about the agony of Tamilians in the run up to the elections, take up the issue? Or is it business as usual?

(Col. R Hariharan, a retired Military Intelligence specialist on South Asia, served as the head of intelligence of the Indian Peace Keeping Force in Sri Lanka 1987-90.He is associated with the South Asia Analysis Group and the Chennai Centre for China Studies. Blog: www.colhariharan.org E-mail:colhari@yahoo.com)

5 Comments

Colonel R.Hariharan was correct in starting his analysis with an obvious fact " The Menik Farm complex and its temporary shelters, showcased last month as model for camps for people displaced due to the war,.. "

Politically the most influential Media Mogul in India, Mr. N.Ram of HINDU,who was also awarded
"Srilanka Rathna " by the GOSL for the services he rendered to SL, propagated not only in SL media or Indian media but made his statement echoed all over the world," THE UPLIFTING EXPERIENCE " HE HAD AFTER VISITING THE MANIK FARM CAMP.On that his news papers and magazines had some pictures to show that uplifting experience to the world in defence of the Mahinda regime.

To the credit of the HINDU paper, after the war was over,it did publish the open letter written by Mr. Krishna Iyer ( former Supreme Court Judge to Rahul Ghandhi and in that he had raise the issue that India has failed the Tamils of Srilanka or something to that effect.

I am little puzzled that in his concluding paragraph
Colonel Hariharan is only blaming or appealing to political jokers ( as labelled by hariharan's counterparts in SL like sarath and Gotha ) of TN "Will some of our worthy parliament members, who spoke eloquently about the agony of Tamilians in the run up to the elections, take up the issue? Or is it business as usual? ". In this matter Colonel Hariharan also has conveniently forgotten the news in record how the deputy high commissioner of SL handled the media people of TN and the TN politicians, during the war and prior to the Indian elections in TN.

It was also in record in Sunday Times that Mahinda regime's Gotha and sarath dealt privately with the Indian trio out side the foregin offices.

From all these it is evident that Colonel Hariharan is appealing to the wrong people who have been controlled by MR regime who in turn has been controlled by outsiders, for an effective and sppedy solution to the IDPs.


Posted by: M.Thiru | August 17, 2009 11:33 PM

Thanks to your government for this Monsoon Miseries.
Easwaran

Posted by: K.Easwaran | August 18, 2009 08:19 AM

Apparently family members of these unfortuante people had been sending money to them. The government has earned valuable foreign exchange from their misery. Now we know why the govt. is keen on installing banks and ATM in the camps than providing food, water and medicine. Family of soldiers are having a brisk sale of milk food and vegetables etc. within the camp at exhobitant rates and doing black market business!! These re beside the ramsom earned by the paramilitary and the soldiers!!
No wonder Mahinda does not want to dismantle the camp. These people are like "gooses that are laying golden eggs" for him. Who cares about their pphysical and mental well being!! After all they are TAMILS!!

Posted by: nandasena | August 18, 2009 12:47 PM

The concern for the Tamil IDPs is understandable. Their lives aren't a bed of roses. However, there is another group of people (Sinhala and Muslim) who live in camps in the Puttalam area, numbering some 200,000 , who were forcibly evicted from their ancestral homes in Jaffna and Vavuniya some 20 years ago,and were barred from carrying away any of their possessions. These people deserve our sympathy and must have priority over the new IDPs. They are not an irritation, to be forgotten or ignored, and their possessions must be restored to them without further delay.

Posted by: Ram2009 | August 19, 2009 03:11 AM

The writer always wrote about the military aspects. This article gives some hope that the innocent civilians will get at least some relief.

Posted by: hasan | August 19, 2009 03:22 AM

Post a comment

(The comment may need to be approved by transcurrents.com. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting; generally approved/posted if they are not abusive of the topic as well as the author and/or another commenter.)

(Please write the comment in paragraphs if its long and allow space between paragraphs, for easier reading by others)

Recent Posts on TC