Dangerously foolish to disregard what this election and its aftermath have highlighted
by Dr. Pakiasothy Saravanamuttu
The Presidential election has been concluded. The results have been announced and they are being contested, most probably in the courts as well. The south voted overwhelmingly one way, the north and east overwhelmingly another. President Rajapaksa is prsident again and his massive majority lies massively in the majority community.
General Fonseka after being holed up in a hotel and surrounded by the military is back at home. His office has been searched, his security detail considerably depleted, a number arrested and the military hierarchy for good measure shaken up and considerably stirred.
He is accused of masterminding a coup and of divulging national security secrets but he has not been charged or arrested on either count. He believes that his life is under threat; the opposition, his supporters and others believe that the election was rigged at the count.
The latter fall into two categories - those who believe that the general won and those who believe that whilst the incumbent may have won his majority was grossly inflated by electoral malpractice. Neither category has yet to produce sufficient hard evidence to substantiate their claim. Some evidence has been reported and there is the promise of more to be produced in the courts and presented to the country at large.
Local monitors were not allowed to observe the count and never have been at previous elections. Some have evidence of the assault and chasing away of counting agents in certain areas and some have faced difficulty in acquiring further evidence on account of a current context of fear. Therefore whilst they acknowledge public doubts, without the sufficient hard evidence they cannot with responsibility dispute the official result on the grounds of widespread malpractice in the count.
The Election Commissioner has rejected charges of malpractice in the count and stands by the official result. He points out that those who contest the result can exercise the option of going to court.
In the meantime a newspaper was sealed, one journalist disappeared and a number of websites blocked. There is jubilation is some quarters – perhaps the majority - shock, dismay and anger in others. Faith and confidence in the integrity of the electoral process if not eroded has been badly dented.
In politics it is perceptions that matter and a significant percentage if not all of the 40 per cent of the electorate that voted for Sarath Fonseka believe that the count was rigged.
In summary this is the political profile of Sri Lanka in the aftermath of its first postwar national election. Disputation of the result of the presidential election notwithstanding, a general election awaits. As to whether the mandate recorded for the president will also be recorded for his party at a general election or as to whether the opposition will fare better, even much better, remains to be seen.
There is the possibility that turn out could be low – a silent protest by those who continue to wonder as to what happened to their vote. This is the real concern that arises from the presidential election – its impact on the faith and confidence of the people in the integrity of the electoral process, the basic process for choice and change in a functioning democracy.
This election, any election should not just be a victory of a single person or party. Above all else it should be an affirmation of the health and strength of democracy as exemplified by the functioning of its institutions and processes.
What happened in the immediate aftermath of the close of polls and the announcement of results has been highlighted above. Action taken ostensibly to stave off a coup and authoritarian government in defiance of the will of the people, turned out to be more offensive than defensive.
It allowed as much for the regime to be seen as vindictive and paranoid with an optimum voter base of over 6 million, as it did the general to be seen as humiliated and pathetic after having just received at least 4 million votes, if you number amongst those who believe the count was rigged.
We have never quite seen a sequence of post- election events like this one. Or an election in this country in which the electoral process was subjected to such stress and strain outside the context of armed conflict. Encapsulating the trauma was the Election Commissioner, way past the age of retirement and in the singular, unenviable position of not being able to do so, given the non-implementation of the Seventeenth Amendment and a Supreme Court order preventing him from doing so.
In his statement announcing the official results, a much harassed Commissioner, listed his woes – from the fiasco of the Competent Authority to the disregard of his authority by public officials to abuse from the general public. Referring to a statement by a key regime media official, that the Commissioner’s job was only to protect ballot boxes and count votes, the Commissioner lamented or perhaps warned that: Under the current situation it may be difficult to even protect the ballot boxes.
That remark in general or in the particular context intended by Mr Dissanayake, is deeply disturbing. As a Polaroid snapshot of our governance it illustrates breakdown and disfunction – a point made in this column when the Commissioner first felt it necessary to publicly vent his frustration and despair in the course of the presidential election campaign.
The regime has to rein in its attack dogs and seriously address the crisis of governance as an urgent priority in the restoration of trust and confidence in the electoral process, given the imminent general election. The hoorays and hosannas of victory must not drown out the undeniable concerns about the integrity of the electoral process.
Mahinda Rajapaksa on being declared the winner of this election proclaimed that he is the president of all of the people of the country, irrespective of whether they voted for him or not. Quite, so. However, what does he mean?
Whilst the courts sift through the evidence and the opposition keeps alive doubt, even consolidates belief to the extent that it can, will the president be moved to use his considerable power and authority to ensure a clean general election?
Is it not time to implement the Seventeenth Amendment in the interests of national unity, reconciliation, democratic governance and yes, national security the value that this regime believes trumps all others?
It would be very foolish, dangerously so, to disregard what this election and its aftermath have highlighted. To do so would compound the challenge of democratic governance as the framework for a post-conflict Sri Lanka and further divide its peoples along the lines of regret and revenge.
6 Comments
Dear Dr Packiasothy,
Thank you for our excellent thoughts.
What you are putting forward is based on a set of western democratic values. There is apparently no space for them in Sri Lanka.
No one cares anyway. The UN is in the hands of the most ineffective Secretary General; he is however ably supported by Vijay Nambiar on Sri Lankan affairs. See how quickly Alston was sidelined following his recent letter on the video.
Prez Obama is busy chasing bandits in the corporate world and innocent civilians in Afghanistan. Hillary is exhausted travelling the globe with a group of 100 followers.
Anyone else who cares? None !
Indian Entrepreneurs are the only group intersted in Sri Lanka; they are out to grab as much land and resources belonging to displaced tamils for quick profit making.
As such, espousing western democratic values will not get anywhere. What's valued are attempted assinations, vote rigging, white van dissapearences, bribery etc etc.
As Dr. Pakiasothy has said what matters in Politics is perception and not the Truth. On that basis, if you have not won, at least pretend that you have. Dr. P openly opposed the Mahinda Rajapakse government, wrote articles supporting Sarath Fonseka, now comes forward to give advice to Rajapakse on how to run the country while repeating at length, the insinuation that election results were rigged, a "computer jilmart" as Somwansa Amarasinghe called it.
The Election Commissioner has pointed out that counting centre results were issued in hard copies. If election results were 'created' at Temple Trees as was said in the rumour circulated via SMS, results could be easily challenged.
I suspect that Sarath Fonseka was fed with a lot of false information, by his handlers and the guy was ready to take over the country on 27th. If he thought that the Government was going to arrest the key members of the opposition, as a brilliant military man would he have collected the lot at one location and make it very easy?
Dear Doctor Saravanamuttu,
This is a well balanced article that tells the truth about what has taken place in our beloved country. It is sad that some who wants to "cling" onto power without regards to so called democratic values & denying the basic rights of the people. I left Sri Lanka a long time ago but has been reading the news, especially when the war was at its critical stages. As such, I have no political affiliation whatsoever with any parties. BUT anyone, including myself can see that the rights of the people has been robbed or there is ample evidence indicating such acts. The commissoner's speech prior to election results itself is enough for one to know that "foul play" was involved. I happen to watch the live telecast of that via webcast on Ada Derana. The look on the EC's face itself told a story.
I have spoken with few relatives and they are all saying that mischief has taken place. I only hope like you have said that the opposition can bring forward the evidence they claim to have and try to get this mess resolved. It doesn't matter who the winner is as long as it is the "true" choice of the majority. Let democracy prevail in Sri Lanka so the future generations can have some belief that the "system" is working in Sri Lanka to at least some extent.
Some educated with bloated egos with vested hidden interest have no backbone to spell a spade as a spade. Instead, they beat about the bush.
There is no election in Sri Lanka that had been held without malice be it the UNP or the SLFT or the TULF or the Red parties or the JVP. BUT to think 1.8m votes have been rigged is utter lunacy.
Fonseka surrounded by hordes of ex-servicemen and deserters indeed smell a rat. Further, Fonseka's bloated ego and arrogance & the Zoological speech added to his deadly remark of a hearsy that surrenderees were shot on orders by Gota through MG Shavendra to the troops made his fall from grace like the Humpty Dumpty.
Whatever anger Fonny may have had against his bosses, nowhere in the world people of Fonny's calibre divulge or threaten to divulge a state's military secrets.
This itself indicate what low pedigreed persons SLA have had to lead her military. Nobody adrees hin as general these days and lost the trust and faith of his men and the masses of the country. Fonny himself was aware since the days of Leader interview that the majority has viewed him a lowbred. Since then, with his more aligned JVP "JILMAALS" with the assistance of the few who was closed to him, and buying over the rest of the ex-militarymen on exorbitant hirepurchase prices allegedly planned to do whatever it was the ultimate thing or prepare the backup plan on the unsuspecting Rajapakshe brood.
Anyway, now when you look at it, the Rajapakshe brood themselves have been ONe Step ahead of this Fonny. it is a matter of time when those investigations continue statements recorded & actual confrontations & verification takes place the general public will come to know Fonny's Libido.
Allow time, the real Fonny will emerge to the public.
Then there is going to be shocks and after shocks and ripples of shocks.
As for right now, the GOSL is arranging their deck of cards back into the proper order.
Probably, JILMAALS and FONNIES will have to find places to hide.Unexpected names will appear.
The vicious hand of the IC, NGO & HR judas will send shock waves.
Masses will be beliwered beyond imagination. Hope, this will not cause mayhem in the country. GE campaign will give rise to many an agenda that will be unearthed.
Rajapakshes will quite rightly will have to SNUFF OUT everyone that was & is involved.
As the president has a albeit questionable mandate to carry out more of the same policies, we cannot expect any improvement. The absolute power and impunity of the excutive is intact and is being used to supress the media and opposition. What next is the question?
The words "17th Amendment" are becoming an anathema to the ruling faction. We were hoping that the President after the resounding victory would show some inclination towards respecting the constitution that confers so much power on him.